ISSUE 016 · The Aroko Letter

Price or Permission

If Washington won't set the rules for building AI, can states and towns step up?

OCT 02, 202612 min readPrimary-source verified

AI INFRASTRUCTUREREGULATORY & POLICYENERGY TRANSITIONCRITICAL MATERIALS

On Sept. 16 the House voted 417 to 3 to let each state decide who pays when a big data center plugs into the grid. Within four days Virginia pulled its support for new data centers, Texas froze permits for them, and California signed seven laws making them pay for their grid upgrades. This issue sorts AI’s inputs on a price-to-permission scale: loans and natural gas cost more but can still be bought, some chip metals need China’s license on China’s calendar, and the grid has a foot in each. It tests the case that the new rules fade against the 1870s railroad laws, and forecasts that states and towns, not Washington, are still writing the grid’s rules a year from now.

Anchor figure

The House voted 417 to 3 to leave the grid’s cost question with the states. Within four days, three of them answered it three different ways.

Key takeaways

States and towns now write the grid’s rules for AI’s biggest customers: who pays for grid upgrades, and whether they get connected at all. Some set a price; others say no for now.
A price can be cleared with money, even if it hurts. A permission only clears with someone else’s yes. Knowing which kind of obstacle a project faces tells you where AI can be built fast and where it has to wait.
Money and gas are getting pricier but are still for sale: the 10-year Treasury closed at 5.24 percent on Sept. 28, its highest since June 2007, and SoftBank paid up to 9.75 percent to fund its final $10 billion OpenAI installment.
Chip metals sit at the permission end. Washington says the US-China truce runs to Jan. 10, but China’s written notices still pause the rare-earth controls only until Nov. 10 and the US ban until Nov. 27.
The forecast, at 55 to 60 percent: September’s grid rules still stand on Sept. 30, 2027, with at least one of Texas, Virginia or California acting to make them stick and none of the three going back to its old rules.

Where it sits in the series

Picks up where Issue 15 ended: if no rule reaches the training run, the binding rules are the ones on power, chips and minerals, and the grid’s are now being written by statehouses and town councils rather than Washington.

READ THE FULL ISSUE Published in full, free, on Beehiiv.